An educational review desk — not affiliated with PDF Gear, iLovePDF, or Smallpdf. No company pays for a place in our columns.

A reviewer's desk at night with blank papers fanned across the surface, lit by one warm lamp

PDF Gear, iLovePDF and Smallpdf compared side by side

Three tools, one set of criteria. This page puts PDF Gear, iLovePDF, and Smallpdf against the same questions so the differences are visible rather than implied. Treat the table as a starting point, then read the individual reviews for the reasoning behind each row.

Jump to the comparison table
First-pass comparison of PDF Gear, iLovePDF and Smallpdf by task
Task PDF Gear iLovePDF Smallpdf
Rewriting text inside a document Built for it Not its job Not its job
Highlights and sticky notes Yes Yes Yes
Working on a document that stays on your PC Yes, on the machine Through a browser Through a browser

Four task rows out of eight. The full ruled table continues below.

How we set up the comparison

Every tool is judged on the same list: editing text inside an existing PDF, annotation and highlighting, form filling and signing, OCR for scans, redaction, offline use, and general platform fit for a Windows PC. Using one list matters more than it sounds. A comparison that lets each product be measured on its own strengths ends up as three advertisements in a row. Ours does not do that.

The seven criteria below are the rows of the table. Each row states what the task actually involves, where each of the three tools stands, and which editor the task tends to favour. Where a tool's support for a task is limited, the individual review explains what happens instead.

Side-by-side comparison of PDF Gear, iLovePDF and Smallpdf across seven editing tasks
Task What the task involves PDF Gear iLovePDF Smallpdf
Editing text inside an existing PDF Reaching into a paragraph and changing the wording, or updating a figure inside a sentence, without rebuilding the page around it. The dividing line in the category. A desktop editor for PC is built to open the document and rewrite the body text in place. Built around adding, combining and converting. Rewriting existing body text is not the workflow it was designed for. Same shape as iLovePDF: strong on assembling documents, limited on changing the sentences already on the page.
Annotation, highlights and comments Marking up a document for someone else: highlights, sticky notes, freehand marks, and whether replies travel back. Handles the annotation layer with the usual tools. Worth checking how the marks export before a document goes to several readers. Standard highlight and note tools in the browser tab. Convenient for a single reviewer, less so for a long comment thread. Comparable toolset to iLovePDF. The practical variation is in how annotations leave the tool and whether others can answer them.
Forms, signing and everyday paperwork Filling in a form, placing a signature, and getting the paperwork back out again without fuss. Covers the same ground from the desktop side, which helps when the files are already on your machine and you would rather not send them anywhere. Often the easiest route for occasional paperwork: open a tab, fill, sign, save the result. Sits alongside iLovePDF here, with the same tab-based convenience for a form that arrives once a month.
OCR and scanned documents Turning a scan into text you can search or edit, rather than a picture of a page. A core feature on the desktop side. This row can decide the choice on its own if you regularly receive scanned contracts. Supported, though the depth differs from a desktop editor. Check the review for how it behaves on a poor-quality scan. Also supported, and again the detail matters more than the yes-or-no. Some tools route scans toward a different workflow entirely.
Redaction and sensitive material Removing the underlying content so it cannot be recovered. This is not the same as drawing a black box over the text. The row where a desktop editor generally has the advantage, because the work happens on your own machine. May only approximate the job. Read that section carefully before relying on it for confidential material. Same caution as iLovePDF: useful for light tidying, not a substitute for a proper redaction pass.
Offline work and file location Whether the document stays on your drive and whether the tool keeps working without a connection. Runs locally. Your files stay on your drive and the work continues when the connection drops. Depends on sending the document to a service and bringing the result back. Client confidentiality and spotty internet both push the other way. Same browser-toolkit model. Very large files and unreliable connections are where this shows up first.
Platform fit for a Windows PC How the tool behaves on a Windows machine, including Windows 11: install, file handling, and everyday speed. A pdf tool for Windows first. This is where pdf gear windows and pdf gear for windows 11 come up most often. Platform-agnostic by design: the browser is the platform, so Windows version matters less. Same browser-first posture. Consistent across machines, with the trade-offs that come with that.

Scroll the table sideways on a narrow screen. The green rule marks the row where the verdict changes category.

Hands turning the pages of a thick printed document under warm light at a dark desk

The rows, one at a time

What each task row actually means for your week

A table compresses. It cannot show you how a toolbar feels after an hour, or whether a dialog makes sense the first time you open it. What it can do is narrow the field, so the seven notes below take each row and say plainly who the task belongs to and what to watch for. Read the ones that match your work, then go to the review of the tool that survived.

Editing text inside an existing PDF

This is the dividing line in the whole category. Desktop editors like PDF Gear are built to reach into a paragraph and change it. Browser toolkits like iLovePDF and Smallpdf are built around adding, combining, and converting rather than rewriting existing body text.

If your work involves correcting wording, updating figures inside a sentence, or restructuring a page, weigh this row heavily. If you only ever add a signature or a stamp, it matters much less. The practical test is simple: open a document you already know well and try to change one sentence in the middle of a page. Whichever tool lets you finish that edit without rebuilding the layout around it is the one that matches this row.

Annotation, highlights and comments

All three handle the annotation layer, and for most people the differences here are minor. Highlights, sticky notes, and drawing tools are standard across the group. The practical variation is in how those annotations export and whether reviewers can respond to them. If your documents travel between several people, check that part in the individual reviews before deciding.

Forms, signing and everyday paperwork

Form filling is where browser tools often feel easiest. iLovePDF and Smallpdf both handle common form and signature tasks in a tab, which suits anyone processing paperwork occasionally. PDF Gear covers the same ground from the desktop side, which helps when the files are already on your machine and you would rather not upload them. The reviews explain the specific limits of each.

OCR and scanned documents

OCR turns a scan into text you can search or edit, and support varies noticeably across tools. Some handle it as a core feature, others route you toward a different workflow entirely. If you regularly receive scanned contracts or archived paper records, this row can decide the purchase on its own. Check the review for your preferred tool rather than assuming the feature exists at the same depth.

Redaction and sensitive material

Redaction is not the same as drawing a black box over text. A proper redaction removes the underlying content so it cannot be recovered. This is a row where desktop editors generally have the advantage, and where a browser tool may only approximate the job. If you handle confidential documents, read that section carefully before relying on any tool.

Offline work and file location

A desktop editor for PC runs locally. Your files stay on your drive, and you can work without a connection. Browser toolkits depend on uploading the document to a service and downloading the result. Neither approach is wrong, but they suit different situations. Client confidentiality, spotty internet, and very large files all push toward the desktop side.

Platform fit for a Windows PC

Windows is the platform most of our readers arrive on, and the three tools answer the question differently. A pdf tool for windows is expected to install, register its file types, and open a document from a folder without ceremony; that is where pdf gear for windows and pdf gear for windows 11 questions come from. The browser tools sidestep the question entirely, because the browser is the platform. That consistency is real, and so is the trade-off that comes with it.

A wide night workspace with blank paper stacked beside a closed laptop under a single lamp

Task by task

Matching the tool to the task

Long-term value is less about the feature list and more about whether the tool still fits your workflow in a year. Pick the category that matches your most frequent task, not your most impressive one.

Merge, split and compress

Assembling a set of pages or shrinking a file before sending it. This is the browser tools' home ground, and they are quick about it. If most of your week looks like this, a pdf editing tool in a tab is enough.

Browser tools

Rewriting an existing document

Correcting wording, swapping a figure inside a sentence, or reflowing a paragraph. A desktop editor is the realistic option here, and the row above is the one that matters.

Desktop editor

Signing and light form work

A contract arrives, you sign it, it goes back. Either category works, so choose on convenience: whichever tool is already open when the document lands.

Either

Scanned paper that needs to be searchable

Archived records, received contracts, older paperwork. Check the OCR row above and then the review, because the depth of support differs more than the feature list suggests.

Check the review

Confidential documents

Material that should not leave the machine. Redaction and file location are the two rows to read, and both lean toward a local desktop editor for PC.

Desktop editor

A mixture of all of the above

Most desks look like this. Pick the category that covers your most frequent task, then keep the other one in reserve for the days it is needed.

Pick the frequent task

If you would rather talk it through with a person, the review desk offers paid consultations at 1 hour = $15 for help with the editors covered on this site. The contact page carries the form and the hours.

A quiet consultation desk at night lit by one warm lamp, with blank paper stacked beside a closed laptop

Where these three sit in the wider market

PDF Gear, iLovePDF, and Smallpdf are not the only choices. PDF-XChange Editor and Foxit PDF Editor are frequently mentioned for feature depth on Windows, while Ashampoo PDF Pro and Kofax Power PDF sit in the conventional desktop bracket.

Among browser tools, Sejda and PDFescape cover light editing and form work, and PDF24 Creator bundles many tasks into a single Windows toolkit. We list them so you can see the alternatives, not to steer you away from the three main reviews.

What the table cannot tell you

A table compresses. It cannot show you how a toolbar feels after an hour, or whether a dialog makes sense the first time you open it. That is what the full reviews are for.

Use the table to narrow the field, then read the review for the tool that survived. If two tools are still tied, the consultation route on the contact page is the slower but more honest way to settle it.

Questions about the table

Short answers to the three things readers ask most about this comparison.

Is the comparison based on paid placements?

No. We do not accept payment for rankings, and no vendor influences the criteria or the results.

Why only three tools in the main table?

These three cover the two main categories well, desktop editing and browser toolkits. We mention other editors in the wider-market section.

Does the table cover Windows 11 specifically?

Yes, platform fit for Windows is one of the criteria, and the Windows choosing guide goes into more detail.

Read the review behind the row

Each review takes one editor and walks through the same seven tasks in full, with the cases where it behaves differently from the summary above. If you would rather have a person walk the table with you, the review desk offers paid consultations at 1 hour = $15 for help with these editors. Reach us Monday to Friday, 9:00 AM to 6:00 PM Pacific Time, at info@pdfeditorreviewdesk.com or +1 213-587-8903.

PDF Editor Review Desk is an educational review site. We are not affiliated with PDF Gear, iLovePDF, Smallpdf, or any other product named on this page, and no vendor has input into the criteria or the rows above.